How We Selected Andover’s Best Roofers

Let’s face it — finding the best roofing in Andover MA can feel like searching for a trustworthy mechanic. Everyone claims they’re “the top roofing contractor,” but not every crew can actually handle New England’s unpredictable weather, steep rooflines, and strict Massachusetts building codes. So, instead of relying on slogans or star ratings alone, I broke it down the way a seasoned roofing consultant would — by looking at what truly matters when choosing the right team for your home or commercial project.

Below is a transparent breakdown of how we handpicked the top roofing companies in Andover MA — the same process I’d use if I were hiring for my own house in the Merrimack Valley.

1. Verified Local Presence and Reputation

Not every roofer with a Boston phone number actually services Andover, North Andover, or Merrimack Valley. We focused on companies with boots-on-the-ground presence — teams that know the unique blend of snow loads, ice dam risks, and zoning quirks of Andover’s older colonial-style homes.
✅ Example: A reputable roof replacement Andover MA specialist will have completed local permits through the Town of Andover Building Division.

We also checked whether they’re part of the community — think local sponsorships, real photos of their crews, and office addresses you can actually drive to.

2. Certifications, Materials & Technical Competence

When I see the words “GAF Certified Roofer in Andover” or “Owens Corning Preferred Contractor,” I pay attention. These credentials mean the roofer isn’t just licensed — they’ve been trained to install full-system roofing components (ice and water shield, ridge vents, and underlayment) that comply with local building codes.

💡 Pro Tip: A standing seam metal roof or EPDM flat roof installation done by certified pros can last 40+ years with minimal upkeep — a smart investment for energy-efficient and commercial properties.

We rated each roofer based on their comfort level with:

• Asphalt shingle roofing Andover homes (most common)
• Metal roofing Andover MA (growing fast for modern builds)
• Flat or low-slope EPDM systems (for commercial roofing Andover MA)
• Ice and water protection upgrades, mandatory in most Andover inspections

3. Customer Reviews and Proven Track Record

Sure, everyone loves a five-star review — but I don’t just look at the score. I look at patterns. Are customers praising their communication? Clean-up? Warranty follow-ups?
Angi, Yelp, and the Better Business Bureau became our filters for long-term consistency, not one-off flukes.

We favored companies that:

• Have at least 5 years of continuous service in the Merrimack Valley
• Show up on time and return calls (a dying art)
• Offer written, transferable roofing warranties in Andover MA

4. Transparency and Value

Nobody wants hidden fees halfway through a reroof. The top local roofing contractors in Andover were the ones who offered itemized quotes — breaking down everything from roof flashing and underlayment to drip edge installation.

Personally, I’d avoid any bid that’s “too good to be true.” Cheaper often means cutting corners on ventilation or skipping ice barriers, and that’s how you end up with roof leaks after the first snowstorm.

5. Responsiveness and Post-Install Support

Your roofer should care about your roof long after the invoice clears. The best roofing companies Andover MA provide post-install inspections, emergency leak responses, and annual roof maintenance programs — especially helpful for preventing ice dam formation in winter.

When reviewing customer feedback, we gave bonus points for:

• 24/7 emergency roof repair Andover
• Proactive communication during bad weather alerts
• Maintenance reminders or free inspections after the first year

6. Warranties, Insurance & Compliance

Finally, no review is complete without checking insurance. Every company on our shortlist carries liability and worker’s comp, plus manufacturer-backed coverage for both labor and materials.

Quick-Glance Comparison Table (Who’s Best For What)

Top 10 Roofing Companies Serving Andover, MA – Updated 2025 Guide

If you're a homeowner or property manager in Andover, MA, and you're looking to replace or repair your roof in 2025, you’re in luck. This updated guide features ten of the most trusted roofing companies that serve Andover and the greater Merrimack Valley area. We've compiled a clear, human-readable summary of what each company offers, along with their reviews, specialties, and unique pros and cons.